Friday, October 9, 2015

Active Shooter "Training"

I work on a federal installation so there is a lot of training that we receive every year. I just went through an Active Shooter training class again. This is something that we get annually and so I’ve been through it before. One of the requirements is to watch a video called “Run, Hide, Fight” which you may have seen before.
This video is not too bad and it contains some good advice. The problem I have with the government is they tend to be myopic in their training. After this training I talked with the instructor whom I have met at my shooting range from time to time. He and I decided that the video gives good advice, but it should be taken with a grain of salt. Reality does not always happen the way the video depicts. Sometimes run, hide, fight might be appropriate, but clearly it is not the best plan for ALL active shooter events. While discussing this with the instructor he sent me some interesting research. Ron Borsch, an ex-paratrooper, ex-swat member, retired police officer, and now trainer, is the leading active shooter specialist. He did some research that should be reviewed in light of active shooter training.
Ron prefers the more descriptive term of “Rapid Mass Murder” over the traditionally-used terms like “active shooter” or “active killer”. Ron defines a “Rapid Mass Murder” (RMM) as “Four or more people being killed in less than 20 minutes in a public location.” That encompasses most active shooter events as well as includes events where the killer used a weapon other than a firearm.
Ron’s statistics through November indicate that 2012 will set a new record in numbers of RMMs. From 1975 through the Columbine massacre, “successful” and attempted RMMs in the US and abroad averaged one per year. Post-Columbine through 2010, the yearly average was four. Last year there were eight, and the total for 2012 through Thanksgiving was 9.
Some additional research you may find interesting (quoted directly from Ron’s newsletter):
Before investing in any theory or propaganda, enlightened administrators and trainers should exclusively examine only successful aborts. “Stopping the killing” only occurs in slightly over half of “Rapid Mass Murder”© incidents. Significant, documented, verifiable, and repeatable research has identified what strategies and tactics work in stopping the killing. In summary, they are:
1. Citizens, mostly unarmed, perform two thirds of all “Rapid Mass Murder”© aborts.
2. In citizen aborts, initiation by a single citizen stops the killing eight out of ten times.
3. Law enforcement performs one third of all “Rapid Mass Murder”© aborts.
4. In law enforcement aborts, initiation by a single officer stops the killing seven out of 10 times.
Where do RMMs occur?
38% Schools, (Pre-school and K-12)
17% Colleges and Universities
10% Church/Religious facility
8% Restaurant/Coffee House
6% Mall/Shopping Center
4% Hospital/Nursing Home
3% Military Base/Facility, tied with Bus Stop/Train
Most Dangerous Months for RMMs
“Our Post-Columbine data indicates that March, (23%), and April (16%) have been the most dangerous months, followed by a 3rd place tie, (11%), between September and December. February and June were tied, (7%); July, August, October, and November were also tied, (5%). January was 6th, (3%), and May has been relatively safest in 7th or last place, (2%).”
In looking at Ron’s research, it is clear that time is of the essence in stopping an active shooter. Law enforcement need to be training in single officer response tactics. If a single unarmed citizen stops more than half of all rapid mass murders, why are cops (who have pistols, rifles, and armor) waiting outside until they can get a “team” to confront the shooter? They really need to change their thinking about that type of response. Some departments are.
Law enforcement (or someone) need to be providing armed citizens with “advanced CCW” classes that prepare them to deal with an active killer. There is far more likely to be an armed citizen already on the scene of a rapid mass murder than a uniformed cop. We need to empower those folks with the knowledge they need to neutralize the shooter. Citizens are already stopping more shooters than the police, why not give them a better chance?

Semper Paratus
Check 6